Martina McBride vs. Carrie Underwood?

Question

Personally, I prefer Martina McBride--especially after hearing her album of classic country song covers, TIMELESS.

Who do you think is better: Martina McBride or Carrie Underwood.

Answer 1

Martina McBride. She's absolutely amazing. I saw her in concert and it sounds like it was recorded it was so incredible. Carrie Underwood is good, but she's got a few years before she comes close to Martina.

Answer 2

Martina McBride

Answer 3

Martina McBride she has alot more in common with her listeners... Im not sayin the carrie doesnt but in really life she as bad as the rest of the idiots out ther.... Martina is not lik that

Answer 4

I haven't heard many Martina McBride songs so I'd say Carrie

Answer 5

Carrie Underwood hasn't been singing long enough to make a good comparison with Martina, for right now Martina is better but I think 8-10 years down the road it could end up being Carrie.

Answer 6

Carrie Underwood

Answer 7

I like more of Martina's music, but that may just be because she's been around longer. I do like some of the music on Carrie's Some Hearts CD, though!

Answer 8

Martina McBride is in my opinion without a doubt. She rocks!!

Answer 9

Martina. I can't understand anything Carrie says.

Answer 10

Martina! Love Carrie, but Martina's voice has it all over hers.

Answer 11

Well I like more of carrie underwood's songs but I would have to say martina. I dont really like carrie but i like her songs.

Answer 12

Martina Mcbride by far i saw her in concert she is awsome

Answer 13

Martina is the best.

Answer 14

Yuck to both! Martina just (excuse my french) bellows everything and Carrie is highly over-rated!

Answer 15

mart hands down

Answer 16

------MARTINA